About Us!

Jim and Ann Reichle opened Angelina's Pizza (North Olmsted) in October of 1994. The second Angelina's Pizza (Olmsted Falls) was opened in January of 1998.

We are very community oriented, serving schools, churches and many other community related activities. Custom catering is available for any sized special event including graduations, rehearsal dinners, funerals and company retreats.

What Makes Us Different?

Our sauce and pizza dough are made fresh daily, Our menu includes: pizza, sandwiches, salads, pastas, wings, appetizers, and a variety of beverages.

It's been our pleasure to serve you since 1994. We've been named Ohio's Best Pizza in both Traditional and Gourmet competitions, Best Pizza in the Midwest and Best Pizza in Elyria among many other accolades over the years. 

We may not be the fastest in delivery but we guarantee when your order arrives it will be the best you've eaten! Taste it for yourself.

If you're not completely satisfied with your order for any reason, please call the store immediately. We will gladly replace your order or refund your money!

Awards/Honors:

BEST PIZZA in Ohio, '96, '97, '98
BEST PIZZA in the Midwest '99

Our Guarantee!

If you are not completely satisfied with our product and service please call our store within one hour of receiving your order. We will gladly refund your purchase price or replace your order. (At least half the order is required to be returned for refund or replacement.)

  Proud supporter of ProStart - A National Restaurant Association student education program.